Permeate Pump

How to Design and Operate a Px® System Part 1

The new pressure exchanger (PX) device transfers the energy from the concentrate stream directly to the feed stream. This direct, positive displacement approach results in a net transfer efficiency of over 95%. Although application of the PX technology is simple in both theory and practice, in order to get the most benefit from this technology it is important to reconsider the SWRO design and operation approach. Pertinent design considerations include pre-filtration, conversion rate optimization; pump selection, and operating pressures. Some important operating procedures and characteristics are start up, high pressure regulation, conversion rate optimization, flow balancing, and shutdown. Furthermore, it will be shown that these considerations affect the design and operation of SWRO systems counter-intuitively and may possibly reverse given standards that have been developed over the past 20 years of SWRO design.
There has been a recent proliferation of commercially available energy recovery devices based on the positive displacement direct pressure exchange approach. This increased interest is driven by the fact that the technology can reduce the energy consumption of an SWRO system by as much as 60%. Since energy costs are rising and can consume as much as 75% of the total operating costs of an SWRO plant, it is important that the technology be encouraged and disseminated throughout the industry. Although the authors of this paper are directly associated with Energy Recovery, Inc., a leading company in pressure exchanger technology, the principles and theories presented in this paper will be applicable to all devices based on the positive displacement, direct pressure exchange approach.
1.0 INTRODUCTION
The PX is a new pressure exchanger device that transfers the energy from the concentrate/reject stream directly to the feed stream in a cylindrical rotor with longitudinal ducts. The rotor spins inside a sleeve between two end covers that divide the rotor into high and low pressure halves. When designing a seawater RO system using the new pressure exchanger device it is only necessary to reconsider the high pressure portion of the system. This is because this is the only portion that differs from earlier RO designs. Pertinent design considerations include conversion rate optimization, pump selection, and operating pressures. Some important operating procedures and characteristics are start up, high pressure regulation, conversion rate optimization, flow balancing, and shutdown. Although application of the pressure exchanger is simple in both theory and practice it is vastly different from typical SWRO design and operation. These differences affect the design and operation of SWRO systems in surprising ways that can be used to improve other aspects of system performance beyond the scope of energy consumption alone.
2.0 PRINCIPLE OF OPERATION

The PX unit utilizes the principle of positive displacement to transfer the energy in the reject stream directly to the feed stream. It is interesting to note that the reject stream is continuously and directly connected to the feed stream. This direct connection allows a real net transfer efficiency of energy from the reject stream to the feed stream of over 95%. The PX device uses a cylindrical rotor with longitudinal ducts parallel to its rotational axis to transfer the pressure energy from the concentrate/reject stream to the feed stream.
The rotor spins inside a sleeve between two end covers with port openings for low and high pressure. The low-pressure side of the rotor fills with seawater while the high-pressure side discharges seawater. The rotation simply facilitates the valving mechanism, which is to transport the ducts from one side to the other.
By rotation the ducts are exposed to the low pressure feed water, which fills the duct and displaces the reject water. The rotor continues to rotate and is exposed to the high-pressure concentrate, which fills the duct from the opposite direction, and displaces the feed water at high pressure. This rotational action is similar to a Gatling machine gun firing high-pressure bullets and being refilled with new seawater cartridges from the muzzle. A liquid piston moves back and forth inside each duct creating a barrier that inhibits mixing between the concentrated reject and new seawater streams. At 1500 rpm one revolution is completed every 1/25 second. Due to this short cycle time, membrane feed water concentrations typically increase only 1%-2%. See Figure 4-1 below.
Applying PX pressure exchanger technology to SWRO is different from conventional energy recovery device system design, but in practice is quite simple. The reject brine from the SWRO membranes is passed into the PX unit, where its pressure energy is transferred directly to a portion of the incoming raw seawater at up to 97% efficiency. This seawater stream, nearly equal in volume and pressure to the reject stream, then passes through a high-pressure booster pump, not the main high-pressure pump. This booster pump is making up the pressure losses across the RO membrane (approx. 2 bar), PX unit(s) (approx. 1 bar) and piping losses (approx. 0.5 bar). The total head provided by the boost pump is typically around 3.5 bar. See figure 4-2 and table 4-1 below.
It is important to notice that the PX and associated boost pump are handling nearly 100% of the reject flow. The size of the main high-pressure pump has been reduced to a make up pump for the permeate flow that is exiting the RO system. Product water flow and reject flow are being provided by two independent pumping systems and therefore are independent of one another.
Since the PX unit is providing nearly 100% of the reject flow at over 95% efficiency there is very little energy penalty associated with increasing this flow and thereby lower the conversion rate of the RO system. At lower conversion rate the pressure required to produce the same amount of product water is lower. Since the main high-pressure pump flow equals the product water flow an energy savings is actually achieved at lower conversion rates.
3.0 CONVERSION OPTIMIZATION
There are many factors that effect RO conversion optimization but none has been more influential than energy consumption. This is because energy costs can be as much as 75% of the entire operating cost of an SWRO plant. In the past the sewater to fresh water conversion rate has had a major and direct impact on the energy consumption of an RO plant. This is because of the inherent shortcomings of the energy recovery and pumping devices that have been used such as the Pelton wheels, turbines, and pumps. These technologies have real/overall net transfer efficiencies of 40-70 percent and are designed to pump the entire feed flow of an RO plant. Therefore at lower conversion rates these inefficient devices are pumping more water. The only way to make these devices pump less water and thereby consume less energy is to increase the conversion rate of the RO system. This is all very logical, and with rising energy costs it is natural that SWRO systems are now being designed at the membrane challenging conversion rates of 50-60%.
System designs with the PX device are different. This is because the PX, a 95% efficient device, is pumping the reject water independently of the product water being produced. The overall energy consumption of an SWRO plant using the PX device has a low point at conversion rates typically between 30-40%. Outside these conversion points the plant will start to consume slightly higher amounts of power. See figure 3 below.
It is important to remember that with the PX device the main high pressure pump flow approximately equals the product water flow. At lower conversion rates it requires lower pressure to produce the same amount of product water. Therefore, the main high-pressure pump will consume less power pumping against less pressure at the lower conversion rates. This phenomenon yields the net energy decrease shown in Figure 3.
Another important point to consider is water quality. In the past, system design had to balance high conversion rate with good water quality. In high salinity applications this has been a difficult challenge. Figure 4 below shows how a lower conversion rate yields better water quality.
Logically combining the kWh/m3 vs Conversion Rate curve of Figure 3 with the diminishing water quality curve as the conversion rate increases in figure 4 shows us that there are good reasons now to consider SWRO designs with lower conversion rates. There are also additional benefits associated with lower conversion rate designs such as ease of operation, fewer cleaning cycles, longer membrane life and a better balance of flux (GFD) from the lead element to the end element in an RO pressure vessel. Figure 5 below shows how GFD is balanced as the system conversion rate lowers(5).
Of course decreasing the system conversion rate does have its disadvantages mainly in increasing the size of the pretreatment system. This effect is less significant in smaller systems under 1000 m3/day because of the less expensive piping materials, pressure media filtration systems and other components typically employed in these systems. However on larger plants using open seawater intakes with large-scale gravity feed media filtration systems, and when the chemical additions associated with coagulation are significant operating costs, conversion rates between 45-50% may be more practical.

About the Author

Wayne M of the American Water Works Assoc writes articles relating to Energy Recovery Inc., a Clean Technology Company that provides affordable Seawater Desalination with the PX Pressure Exchanger which reduces energy costs up to 98%.

Reverse Osmosis 2A, Subpart b – Whole House Adaptation

RO 5 Stage + DI + Permeate Pump/100/150 gpd Reverse Osmosis System Water Filter $250.95

Reverse Osmosis System 6 Stage RO 80 gpd + UV+ Permeate Pump/Water Filter Tank $264.95

RO Reverse Osmosis 6 Stage DI Wster Filter w/Permeate Pump 75 GPD $155.00

PERMEATE PUMP 90% SHUTOFF REVERSE OSMOSIS WATER FILTER $17.95

100 GPD RO Reverse Osmosis 6 Stage water filter w/Permeate Pump A1 $149.00

Reverse Osmosis System-Clear 5 Stage 80gpd UV/Booster/Permeate Pumps No Tank $269.95

RO 6 Stage 24/35/50 gpd Reverse Osmosis System+ UV+ Permeate Pump Water Filter $237.95

Reverse Osmosis System-White 5 Stage 80gpd RO w/Tank UV/Booster/Permeate Pump $289.95

Reverse Osmosis System-Clear 5 Stage RO DI Permeate Pump/80g Water Filter w/Tank $224.95

Oceanic 6 stage Reverse Osmosis Water Filter REMINERLIZER Permeate Pump 75 gpd $154.00

PREMIER REVERSE OSMOSIS WATER FILTER SYSTEM booster and permeate pump UV $356.25

Oceanic Reverse Osmosis Dual Drinking & Aquarium Filter System w/ Permeate Pump $185.00

100 GPD RO Reverse Osmosis 6 Stage w/Permeate Pump a2 $185.00

Reverse Osmosis Permeate Pump For RO Water Filter 50GPD $49.90

AQUATEC PERMEATE PUMP ERP1000 $41.60

Permeate Pump ( for Reverse Osmosis ro r o filter) $49.45

Oceanic Reverse Osmosis Drinking Water Filter System Permeate Pump Alkaline 75 G $179.00

6 STAGE REVERSE OSMOSIS WATER FILTER REMINERALIZER & PERMEATE PUMP 100GPD $179.00

Permeate Pumps with Clips $59.95

Extra Duty Reverse Osmosis Unit / Permeate Pump $194.95

Hurricane Dual Home/Reef with Permeate Pump & Tank $219.95

6 Stage RO + UV + Permeate Pump Reverse Osmosis / Tank $254.95

6 Stage RO 80gpd White UV Permeate Pump Reverse Osmosis System Tank Water Filter $269.95

RO Reverse Osmosis Drinking Water Filter Permeate Pump $279.00

4 Stage Reverse Osmosis Water Filter System With Permeate Pump – Titan Water Pro $169.00

3 Stage RO 24/35/50gpd Reverse Osmosis System Permeate Pump Water Filter Tank $212.95

6 Stage RO 80gpd UV Permeate Pump Reverse Osmosis System Water Filter Clear tank $269.95

5 Stage RO 80gpd Reverse Osmosis System UV Permeate Pump White! NT Water Filter $219.95

5 Stage RO 80gpd Reverse Osmosis System UV Permeate Pump clear NT Water Filter $224.95

5 Stage RO + UV Reverse Osmosis System 80gpd white Permeate Pump Water Filter $254.95

6 Stage Reverse Osmosis System 80gpd RO UV Permeate Pump White Water Filter H2O $226.95

RO 6 Stage 80 gpd Reverse Osmosis System+ UV+ Permeate Pump Clear Water Filter $241.95

5 STAGE REVERSE OSMOSIS WATER FILTER WITH PERMEATE PUMP $169.00

REVERSE OSMOSIS WATER FILTER WITH PERMEATE PUMP + DI 6 STAGE 100GPD GOOD DEAL!! $170.10

Reverse Osmosis System 3 Stage 80GPD Permeate Pump Tank Water Filter 1/4″ Ports $209.95

3 Stage RO System 80 gpd membrane + Permeate Pump Reverse Osmosis Water Filter $212.95

Reverse Osmosis Drinking Water Filter System Permeate Pump DUAL DI/DRINKING & UV $283.10

4 Stage RO System 80 gpd membrane + Permeate Pump Reverse Osmosis Water Filter $214.95

Reverse Osmosis System 3 Stage 80GPD – Permeate Pump – RO Water Filter – Tank $209.95

Premier Reverse Osmosis Drinking Water Filter System Permeate Pump 100 GPD USA $160.55

Premier Reverse Osmosis Drinking Water Filter System Permeate Pump 5 Stage 100G $170.05

Premier Reverse Osmosis Drinking Water Filter System Permeate Pump with Alkaline $179.55

Reverse Osmosis Drinking Water Filter System Permeate Pump DUAL DI/DRINKING $184.30

Reverse Osmosis System 3 Stage 80gpd NT Clear Permeate Pump Water Filter $176.95

3 Stage RO System Permeate Pump Reverse Osmosis 80gpd Water Filter NT H2O White! $174.95

5 Stage 24/35/50gpd! Reverse Osmosis System Permeate Pump White NT Water Filter $185.95

Permeate Pump Upgrade Kit for Reverse Osmosis System $65.00

AQUATEC PERMEATE PUMP ERP500 $57.89

AQUATEC ERP 500 PAM 500 PERMEATE PUMP $44.49

AQUATEC ERP 1000 PAM 1000 PERMEATE PUMP $53.79

5 Stage RO 100/150gpd Reverse Osmosis System Permeate Pump White NT Water Filter $215.95

Permeate Pump Aquatec ERP 1000 no electricity Reverse Osmosis Filter QC fitting $48.00

Reverse Osmosis 6 Stage 24/35/50gpdRO/UV/ DI/Booster/Permeate Pump Water Filter $270.95

5 Stage RO / UV 100/150 gpd Reverse Osmosis System Permeate Pump Water Filter $280.95

Reverse Osmosis 5 Stage RO / UV 100/150gpd/Booster/Permeate Pump Water Filter $293.95

5 Stage Reverse Osmosis System 24/35/50 gpd +Permeate Pump / RO Water Filter $190.95

5 Stage 100/150 gpd RO + UV + Permeate Pump Reverse Osmosis System Water Filter $245.95

Reverse Osmosis 6 Stage 100/150gpd RO+DI+Booster Pump+Permeate Pump Water Filter $318.95

Permeate Pump Aquatec ERP 1000 no electricity Reverse Osmosis Filter QC fitting $52.00

6 Stage 100/150 gpd RO+ DI+UV+Permeate Pump Reverse Osmosis System Water Filter $280.95

Permeate Pump ERP 1000 Upgrade Kit with 90% auto shut off valve, clip, tubing $79.25

Quiet Permeate Pump ERP 500 Upgrade Kit, 90% auto shut off valve, clip, tubing $79.25

5 Stage Reverse Osmosis Water System with Permeate Pump $189.00

REVERSE OSMOSIS DRINKING WATER SYSTEM W/PERMEATE PUMP $269.00

5 Stage RO 24/35/50 gpd + UV + Permeate Pump Reverse Osmosis System Water Filter $220.95

Reverse Osmosis System 4 Stage 24/35/50 gpd + Booster & Permeate Pumps RO $260.95

Reverse Osmosis System RO 5 Stage 100/150gpd)+Permeate Pump+Tank Water Filter $245.95

Reverse Osmosis 5 Stage 80gpd – DI – Permeate Pump – (Clear) Water Filter $199.95

Reverse Osmosis System 4 Stage RO 24/35/50gpd Booster & Permeate Pump White NT $225.95

Reverse Osmosis 5 Stage System 80gpd clear Permeate Pump+Tank Water Filter RO $219.95

5 Stage Reverse Osmosis System 80gpd(white)Permeate Pump Water Filter White Tank $219.95

4 Stage RO 80gpd Booster/Permeate Pump Reverse Osmosis System Cl NT Water Filter $234.95

5 Stage Reverse Osmosis System 80gpd(Clear)Permeate Pump RO Cl NT Water Filter $194.95

5 Stage 80gpd Reverse Osmosis System Permeate Pump White NT Water Filter RO H2O $189.95

Reverse Osmosis System 4 Stage 100/150gpd Booster/Permeate Pump/RO White NT H2O! $255.95

6 Stage RO DI UV 80g Permeate Pump Clear Tank Reverse Osmosis System H2O Splash $269.95

PERMEATE PUMP Reverse Osmosis Water Filter System 50GPD $189.00

4 Stage RO 80gpd Booster/Permeate Pumps Reverse Osmosis System H2O Clear w/tank $269.95

Reverse Osmosis System 4 Stage 100/150gpd Booster/Permeate Pumps RO White w/tank $290.95

4 Stage RO 100/150gpd Booster/Permeate Pump Reverse Osmosis System Clear w/tank! $305.95

Reverse Osmosis System-Clear 100/150gpd 5 Stage UV/Booster/Permeate Pump w/Tank $325.95

Reverse Osmosis System 6 Stage 80g RO/DI/UV/Booster/Permeate Pump Water Filter! $269.95

100 GPD RO Reverse Osmosis 6 Stage Permeate Pump 3 NEW $185.00

6 STAGE REVERSE OSMOSIS WATER FILTER WITH PERMEATE PUMP $179.55

5 STAGE REVERSE OSMOSIS WATER FILTER WITH PERMEATE PUMP $160.55

6 stage Reverse Osmosis Water Filter with Permeate Pump $189.00

5 stage Reverse Osmosis Water Filter with Permeate Pump $169.00

Reverse Osmosis System 4 Stage 80gpd Booster & Permeate Pumps/RO Water Filter $229.95

6 Stage Reverse Osmosis System 100/150gpd RO UV Permeate Pump White Water Filter $226.95

6 STAGE REVERSE OSMOSIS WATER FILTER WITH PERMEATE PUMP $179.00

Reverse Osmosis System 80g 4 Stage Booster/Permeate Pumps/RO Water Filter w/tank $264.95

Reverse Osmosis System 24/35/50 5 Stage Clear UV/Booster/Permeate Pump-Tank H2O $295.95

AQUATEC Permeate Pump Reverse Osmosis System ERP1000 BONUS U-CLIP ELBOW FITTING $54.99

Reverse Osmosis 4 Stage System 80gpd Clear Permeate Pump RO Water Filter NT H2O! $185.95

5 Stage Reverse Osmosis System 100/150gpd Permeate Pump RO Water Filter NT Clear $220.95

RO 6 Stage 100/150gpd Reverse Osmosis System UV Permeate Pump Clear Water Filter $247.95

Reverse Osmosis 4 Stage System RO 100/150gpd membrane Permeate Pump Water Filter $188.95

Oceanic 6 stage Reverse Osmosis Water Filter Alkaline with Permeate Pump 100 GPD $199.00

Oceanic 6 stage Reverse Osmosis Water Filter REMINERLIZER Permeate Pump 100 GPD $189.00

6 STAGE REVERSE OSMOSIS WATER FILTER ALKALINE SYSTEM & PERMEATE PUMP 100GPD $189.05

Tap Master TMAFC Artesian Full Contact Reverse Osmosis Under Counter Water Filtration System, White $419.95 …

Watts Premier 531418 EZ RO4 Reverse Osmosis with QC 50 GPD Membrane $250.00 531418 Features: -Water filtration system.-Four stage 50 gallon per day reverse osmosis system.-Compact design and size makes it a great choice.-Stage one: Five-micron sediment filter reduces dirt, sand, silt, sediment, and rust.-Stage Two: Five-micron coconut shell carbon block filter reduces chloramine, chlorine taste, and odor.-Stage three: Semi-permeable reverse osmosis membrane effectively r…

ERP1000-JG-S – Aquatec Permeate Pump 10-100 GPD $45.00 Description: Male Stems for Connection to 5/16″ x 1/4″ Quick Connect Fittings with clip…

Watts WP5-50 Premier Five-Stage Manifold Reverse Osmosis Water Treatment System $169.99 The Watts Premier Five-Stage Reverse Osmosis Water Filtration Device is the most complete water filtration system available on the market. Featuring a five-stage filtration process, the RO incorporates sediment, coconut-shell carbon, and reverse osmosis technologies to provide great-tasting, bottled-quality water straight from your tap.Other ProductsYou May Want to Consider:All-in-One Water Test K…

Amore Laneige Hydra Solution Essence 40ml $40.99 Allure’s “Best of Beauty” 2009 Winner in Moisturizing Essence Division Laneige Hydra Solution Essence - Contains freshly preserved Himalaya Snow water components intensively, and lightly bursts into water drop texture with gentle rub. Hydra Solution Essence immediately permeates into Skin like melting Snow providing Hydra-energy promptly. - Speedy and powerful Hydra-energy offers deep hydratio…